I have been a musician my whole life...specializing in Bass, recently learning how to play guitar and record ALL instruments.....results on display here.

Playlists

This Artist has 1 Playlist

Comments

Author
Warren Hein
over 30 days ago to concreteblue

hello concrete man, thank you for adding my duet version of Dirty Mama to your list, I'm flattered buddy, many thanks, all the best Warren Hein



Thanks for your review anyway, although I appreciate the perspective of the recording side of it, I don't think your critique was clear enough in explaining your thoughts on why you say for instance "Lacks Originality". Is it because you view bad recordings themselves as non-original, or is it because the song isn't original, that it sounds like something you've heard before. Your review is appreciated, but if you're going to critique a negative point, then please explain the reasons for the critique point. You correctly explained the bad recording...thanks for that. You didn't explain the critique for the other points, both good and bad. I look forward to your next review of one of my songs. Thanks.

5 Replies
 
concreteblue
over 30 days ago

I thought I was clear. But really, if I cannot hear a word you are saying, how could I judge it for originality? No offense intended at all. Without hearing THE SONG I cannot rate any aspect of it.

SpeirosEsteropoulos990135
over 30 days ago

Well, firstly, to say it's a bad recording is a good point, and is something I'm very clear with, as I unforunately don't have the means to do any better.

Secondly, to clarify the "I cannot hear a word you are saying" is great, as now I know that you can't "hear a word I am saying".

Thanks for your critique.

SpeirosEsteropoulos990135
over 30 days ago

As an afterthought, how can you even critique "lacks originality" then if you don't know what I'm saying? Do you listen to mumbling often? lol

concreteblue
over 30 days ago

Dude.....

SpeirosEsteropoulos990135
over 30 days ago

All good man. I appreciate your points, but the whole reason I said other stuff is that the explanation wasn't clear man. There isn't offense taken, but the point I'm getting at is just on the critique wasn't clear, nor defined, but still, I appreciate it. Seriously, two things. 1) Thanks for bothering to put the effort in, in the first place. 2) I DO appreciate the perspective of the bad recording, although this isn't something that will change unless finances change (and therefore, that is good reason for "bad recording" critique), and 3) I hope you continue to give critique for me and for others, but just want to show that sometimes what is said isn't clear to the artist/songwriter, and when the opportunity arises, we ALL (such as me and my bad recording) need to be shown what parts might need work.



Author
Tony James
over 30 days ago to concreteblue

Thanks for reviewing "Never Let Her Go"... much appreciated.
best regards
Tony



Clean Clean

Clean Clean

Artist Name
00:00 / 00:00